Protecting Families for Generations

Andrew Schaefer Head Shot
Andrew Schaefer
Stackowicz Agency
2453 N. Delaware Street
Indianapolis 46205

Andrew Schaefer

Andrew has been a member of the Knights of Columbus since 2023, drawn to its mission of supporting families, parishes, and the broader community through faith and service. He is a parishioner of Holy Redeemer Church in Evansville and an active member of the Holy Redeemer council.

Before working for the Knights professionally, Andrew spend two years serving as a Catholic missionary, traveling throughout the Midwest and working closely with middle school and high school students. During that time, he saw the Lord at work through the families he encountered, which shaped his desire to serve others in a deeper and more intentional way. Andrew continues that missionary spirit today by helping with his parish's youth ministry program.

In October 2025, Andrew began following in his father's footsteps by becoming a licensed life insurance agent with the Knights of Columbus. He serves families across Southern Indians-including Evansville, Daylight, Rockport, Boonville, Princeton and Vincennes-by building trust, offering clear and personalized guidance, and helping protect what families have worked hard to build while supporting growth in both faith and finances.

Andrew is unmarried and values the importance of family and vocation in his personal and professional life. Outside of work and parish life, Andrew enjoys archery shooting and deer hunting, where the stillness of time spent outdoors fosters discipline and draws him closer to the Lord.

Andrew prays continually for the families he has met with and the families he continues to serve.

Auspice Maria

For additional information on investment opportunities provided by our affiliate Knights of Columbus Asset Advisors, please visit www.kofcassetadvisors.org.

Join the Knights of Columbus!

Use agent referral ASCHAEFER to join for free!


Join Now
Catholic Family Finance

Catholic Family Finance

Protecting Catholic families through insurance and financial services: it's not just a member benefit. It's why we exist.

Learn More
Permanent Life Insurance

Permanent Life Insurance

Our signature product provides money to your family when you die while building cash value during your life. Guaranteed, secure and dynamic.

Learn More
Term Life Insurance

Term Life Insurance

Affordable protection for your family's temporary needs. Simple and straightforward.

Learn More
Retirement Annuities

Retirement Annuities

Retirement savings that pay out a regular income stream whenever you're ready to stop making contributions.

Learn More
Long Term Care Insurance

Long Term Care Insurance

Help for your long-term care insurance medical care needs, either in a nursing home or in the comfort of your own home.

Learn More
Test

Disability Income Insurance

A replacement for income lost due to a disability, illness or accident that keeps you from working.

Learn More

Catholic Investing

Knights of Columbus Asset Advisors (KoCAA) can help you and your family pursue your financial goals using a wealth of investment products that may suit your life and your faith.

With an investment portfolio over $28 billion strong and a commitment to the socially responsible investment guidelines set by the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops (USCCB), KoCAA offers clients a variety of investment products designed to assure clients that their personal funds are invested in companies committed to sound ethical, environmental, social, and corporate governance practices.

We provide “value with values” — by helping clients grow their future with faith-based investing.

Learn More
2453 N. Delaware Street Indianapolis, 46205